Lifelong Middletown Resident Says Wind Turbines Forced Her to Move
Tracie Spooner said the turbine on Mitchell's Lane drove her out of Middletown.
The following is a letter to the editor from Tracie Spooner, a lifetime resident of Middletown who said she moved away because of the wind turbines. The Middletown Town Council recently proposed an ordinance that would restrict the placement of turbines in Middletown. Once the ordinance has been drafted by the administration, it will go before a series of public meetings and the council will vote to approve it into law.
Dear Editor:
I have read a lot of negative comments recently directed towards the town council and specifically Councilor Chris Semonelli regarding the decision to restrict wind turbines in Middletown, and I felt that I needed to address this topic since I have had my own personal experiences with the wind turbines on Mitchell’s Lane.
I use to live right next door to the wind turbines on Mitchell’s Lane, they were approximately 100 feet from my property line. I wish I had a councilor like Chris Semonelli back in 2008 when the wind turbines on Mitchell’s Lane were being approved. Approving those wind turbines was the final straw which drove me and my husband out of Middletown - where we grew up, went to school, and planned to retire.
We went to the meeting, they had one meeting – yes, one meeting. We tried to fight it because there was no ordinance in place back in 2008. The plans passed within a half-hour, even though there was no research done; there was no impact survey; and no certified testing. The only information presented to the zoning committee was a brochure that was produced by the seller of the wind turbines.
The seller of the wind turbines was the person who presented the plans to the zoning committee for the Mitchell’s Lane resident. I would like to point out that a month earlier, Portsmouth Town Council had just rejected plans for a similar 60-foot turbine in the Glenn Farm/Sandy Point farm area from this same seller because he did not have adequate testing or surveys done.
I don’t believe wind turbines should be installed in areas that are zoned for residential living and I don’t think there should be any exceptions. I had the misfortune of living next to the wind turbines for a year after they were put up, so from personal experience, I can tell you they are not quiet.
During the meeting in 2008, the seller of the wind turbines stated that the noise level is the same decimal level as a conversation which is just not true. There is a light humming noise that emanates from the turbines at all times and when the blades are spinning, it is more like a small engine plane flying overheard. The flicker effect is extremely annoying, especially if the sun is hitting it the right way; it’s sort of a vertigo effect. I work from home and I had to move my office into the basement in an isolated room to try to avoid the humming noise all day.
I find it disturbing that people would make comments on issues that they do not have first hand experience with. Don’t get me wrong, I’m all for 'Green', but you also have to take into consideration a person’s quality of life” and kudos to Chris Semonelli for actually considering the residents of Middletown and how the wind turbines could impact them.
Tracie Spooner
frank maloof
4:26 pm on Wednesday, March 21, 2012
people who live by turbines should be given something to ease the pain free power? a little check once a month? a tax break?
Sunny Shores
9:02 am on Thursday, March 22, 2012
According to this letter the turbines' noise and flicker are what forced them to move. I don't understand how "free power? a little check once a month? a tax break?" would have made life in their home more tolerable for this couple.
Money doesn't fix quality of life issues......
Tom
2:44 am on Friday, April 6, 2012
Great idea. I'm all for it. If you want a wind turbine, you owe compensation to your neighbors. Free electricity and the town compensated you with lower property taxes. That's a deal I'd be willing to listen to.
2nd Beach
10:34 am on Thursday, March 22, 2012
Just a thought…. But perhaps the Town Council members that support Wind Turbines in residential areas should “volunteer’ their property to audit the claims of the manufactures… Perhaps the manufactures should loan the equipment for the trials considering they are the ones that stand to profit.
Then those council members can report back as to their findings….
As elected officials with only the best interests of their constituents in mind… and never their own “agendas”… I’m sure they will be honest and transparent as to the data….
Cheese Ball
2:08 pm on Thursday, March 22, 2012
So dramatic. You moved your residents because of the neighbor's turbine. Write a book. I would like to ask the ignorant questions; did the turbine make a loud noise from the start? Did it progressively get louder? Was it properly maintained? Did you ever ask the owner to move it to the other side of the property, further from your home? I don't agree that you should have to feel uncomfortable in your own home. You pay your taxes and have been here your whole life, but I wonder what other steps you took aside from crying to a panel of deaf ears. Is there a noise ordinance in Middletown like in Newport? I just feel like a different approach could have been taken instead of moving out of town. Excuse my ignorance.
frank maloof
2:56 pm on Thursday, March 22, 2012
the bottom line is there will never be wind power or solar power until all the fossil fuel is gone the high cost of gasoline comes and goes high today down next year right now its a hot button if it drops 50cents you forget all about it i give up let the next generation fix it all for now nothing will change
Cheese Ball
6:33 pm on Thursday, March 22, 2012
Ok now I don't feel so ignorant. How can you think that way? I'm willing to bet if anyone against wind and solar power were to either A: do there homework, or B: own a turbine or solar panel, they would be singing a different song right now. The select group of individuals who put up a stink about this are just stubborn and set in there ways. Obviously change isn't something everyone is on board with.
Tracie Spooner
9:54 am on Friday, March 23, 2012
Please note, I am not opposed to solar power and alternative sources of energy, I am opposed to it being in my backyard. I am not opposed to wind turbines in industrial zoned areas where it benefits multiple entities; I have a problem with putting up 60 foot+ turbines in a residential zoned area.
frank maloof
2:48 pm on Friday, March 23, 2012
look if its true that one % of the population controls the wealth in this country nothing will change until high energy costs put a dent in the one % pocket thats just the way it works you wont see another turbine on that island of yours and my god if you want solar on your roof you best have no neighbors thats just how things work
frank maloof
3:28 pm on Friday, March 23, 2012
its the good old not in my neighborhood thing
frank maloof
4:44 pm on Friday, March 23, 2012
this talk of solar,wind electric power has been going on for about 40 years now nothing has changed nothing will until people with power feel the pinch thats just the way it is