Should Active Military Be Allowed To Drink Under 21?
A lawmaker would like to make it legal for military service members between the ages of 18 and 21 to drink alcohol
A bill expected to be heard at the State House Wednesday that would make it legal for military service members between the ages of 18 and 21 to drink alcohol in Rhode Island. The legislation (H 5603), introduced by Rep. Thomas Winfield (D-Glocester, Smithfield) would apply to active military members with a valid military identification.
Last June, Middetown Police issued several underage drinking summons after they responded to a farewell party for a soldier who was deployed to Afghanistan. A 21-year-old and a 22-year-old, were cited under the social host ordinance.
Writing from Afghanistan on Tuesday, the solider provided the following statement on Patch (corrected for typos), “If I'm getting shipped off to Afghanistan to fulfill my duty as a soldier, willing to lay my life for my friends and other soldiers around me (someone else's daughter, son, dad, cousin) then I think I deserve a drink.”
On the Middletown Patch Facebook page, many agreed:
Don Bosch My 18 year old son, who heads to Afghanistan in May, puts it this way: I'm old enough to fight for my country, but not old enough to have a beer with my dad? Doesn't seem right.
Doug Paquin I'm with Don. My oldest son is in basic training now and i feel the same way.
Chris Jordan Yes. They would die for our country. GIVE THEM A DRINK!!!!!!
Ron Janior yes of course and always felt that way. bottoms up to the brave!
What do you think? Should active members of the military be able to legally drink in Rhode Island?
MEVM
9:49 am on Wednesday, March 6, 2013
Let them have a drink WITH THEIR FOLKS AND FRIENDS before they deploy....not out in bars getting stupid drunk and then causing havoc on the roads!!! All of our soldiers deserve a huge pat on the back, especially those that are going to be in harms way!
m63224
11:32 am on Wednesday, March 6, 2013
I say either everyone 18-20 can drink, or no one. Yes, it is ridiculous that someone in the military cannot have a beer before deploying, by why should they be singled out for an exemption, especially when they voluntarily joined?
And furthermore, if one is an active military member at age 18, 19, or 20, would it not make since that many of their friends would also be of the same or similar age? Assuming they are (which I think is a fair assumption to make), these under 21 friends would probably like to wish their friend off alongside other under 21 military members and 21+ family/friends, and in doing so, would most likely share in a toast, at a minimum, making their actions, and by association, the host/party as a whole, illegal.
The 21yo minimum drinking age was instituted due to the larger amount of motor vehicle fatalities from when the min. age was lower (18). The better idea would be to lower the min. age to 18 for all, let parents do their jobs and educate their children properly, and maybe start actually teaching our children to drive properly and responsibly instead of having them take the car around the block as the only qualifier to obtaining their license. This seems to work well elsewhere, perhaps it's worth a shot here, too?
Chris Christensen
1:41 pm on Wednesday, March 6, 2013
As a retired Army Sgt I say no. Being military and on Active Duty an under 21 person is just as stupid in their drinking habits and conduct too as a civilian. I entered the service in RI and I was 18 and had to live with it (the law). All the reasons given to allow it are just BS.
Tom
12:24 pm on Tuesday, March 12, 2013
A retired Army Sgt? How on earth do you retire as an E-5 (unless it's a medical retirement)? Let our boys drink. They deserve it.