Letter: Too Much Weight Given to My Wind Turbine Comments

Middletown resident John Byrne submitted the following letter.

To the editor:

There has been much discussion regarding the wind turbine survey and the apparent impact that one neighbor has had on the outcome. I am that neighbor, and my opinion actually differs from that being portrayed.

I agreed to meet with the three Town Council members at my home, and I commend them for taking the time to meet with a constituent to further discuss the balanced comments that I had put in my survey response. But what has transpired since then appears to have resulted in my opinion being given far too much weight in the formation of a town wide policy on turbines.

I want to state that I do not have a blanket opinion on turbines one way or the other, my personal opinion is that the installation of turbines should be looked at on a case by case basis. Let the neighbors have a say in the matter, rather than approving general installation in particular areas of town or on particular types of property.

I opened our discussion by stating the fact that I do not have a problem with the two turbines across the street. Furthermore I added that we have never approached our neighbor with any sort of complaint about the turbines.

The front of my house faces the 55’ turbines, turbines do make noise but the level of noise from these units, in my opinion, is acceptable in our personal situation. The noises are not something that can be measured in decibels; the comment about sounding like a fire engine missed out on some critical words, the sound is actually more like that of a distant fire engine siren. The flicker effect happens for a few short minutes at a particular time of the year, only if there are no clouds in the sky and the wind is coming from the south east at around 7am, so this is a tall order given the variety of weather conditions that we experience on the Island. The flutter noise happens when the small blades spin quickly during high wind, but nobody has ever lost any sleep in my house because of the turbines.

During our discussion I also suggested that the town should look at directly surveying the people that live around these turbines to see what their opinions are, adding that I was surprised that nobody had actually gone out and done this. This begs another question, why hasn’t anyone approached the owner of the turbines on Mitchell’s Lane and asked them first hand about their experiences, has it been worth it, would they do it again, has anyone ever complained about the turbines?

Before purchasing anything large we all have a tendency to garner knowledge from reviews of products whether that be from reputable magazines or actual users. I consider myself to be a user when it comes to proximity to turbines, I have merely given a review and it should, like others, be considered as such.

John Byrne
Middletown RI

SHS March 05, 2012 at 05:28 PM
I find it interesting the degree to which the "real" comments by John Byrne differ from a town council member's description/interpretation of said comments. Wow. Thanks John, for your thoughtful clarification of your opnion on wind turbines. Middletown, take note!
Charles March 06, 2012 at 06:46 PM
It was very clear to me from the start that certain members of this council were just looking for an excuse to ban wind turbines in town. Maybe not the exact words spoken, but when someone makes a comment like "I wanted to find a reason to support wind turbines" that pretty much tells me they don't currently support them, and are probably really looking for a better reason not to. Thanks for the clarification John.
SAM March 06, 2012 at 07:13 PM
it is clear to me that the Middletown council has there own agenda. The answer is putting the turbines is the right area with the right set backs. Why just famers? If I own a large parcel of land and conform to the set backs why cant I own a windturbine??? If you eliminate all the areas that do not have the proper setbacks and then look at the places that have good wind spots you elimante most of the town!!! If our council (a select few) were smart they would see this!!!! Why not start doing something postive!!! Sam
cassie lea September 19, 2012 at 06:07 PM
What type of person representing the town would twist a man's story so out of proportion? It seems someone has egg on their face!!! Thanks for speaking the truth John!! I still dont see the reason for such odd behavior by a few sour councilmen when discussing Mitchells Lane type wind turbines. I consider them to be most appropriate in this day and age and would love to buy one for my husband for a anniversary gift! But, alas....the Middletown Town Council says I can't! BOO!


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »